Discussions about eggcorns and related topics
You are not logged in.
Registrations were closed for a long time because of forum spam, but I have re-opened them on a trial basis.
The forum administrator (chris dot waigl at gmail dot com) reserves the right to request users to plausibly demonstrate that they are real people with an interest in the topic of eggcorns. Otherwise they may be removed with no further justification. Likewise, accounts that have not been used for posting may be removed.
Thanks for your understanding.
Chris -- 2015-05-30
Found on the Finale mailing list at the Sam Houston University:
“I’ve posted brief inquiries to this forum on a couple of occasions, and you guys have been unbelievably helpful. I would like to pose another question, if I may.
I do a (very) limited amount of choral composition and arranging (both open and closed score, accompanied and acapulco) for both liturgical and concert purposes.”
acapulco = a capella (unaccompanied)
When I first saw btouburg’s post, I assumed that this had to be a flukey loner. But I googled it anyhow. Nope, this is widespread, showing up in all sorts of places. The first citation below, for instance, is from a blog post written by poet Bob Holman, who produced the United States of Poetry program for PBS. (Judging from the post, he also has excellent taste in art-rock.)
But is this really an eggcorn? My first instinct would have been to say, no, this is just a malapropism driven by the shared structure of “acap-l-.” But notice that a number of writers have capitalized “Acapulco,” apparently rationalizing the malapropropism and interpreting it to mean something like “in the style of the singers of Acapulco.” So now I’d say that the capitalized versions at least are candidates for eggcorn status. And is this a “jewel in English usage”? Well, I like it.
Doll kicked Celtic R&B, told tales, did an Acapulco version
of “Paper Roses,” and flamed through the strobes of the 70’s.
And it sounds fine when you sing it Acapulco, too.
http://www.mudcat.org/thread.cfm?thread … essages=15
“I’m goiing to sing Pieces of Me, but being that I don’t have my band here, I’m gonna sing it Acapulco”. So she starts singing and there’s this kid in a wheelchair asking “Hey Ashlee, you ever think about changing your song’s name from Pieces of Me to Pieces of Sh—” and they cut it at that point.
http://188.8.131.52/search?q=cache:McIl … o%22&hl=en
‘Suggestion’ is an extremely rousing version, renamed ‘Saying No in Den Haag’ by Ed. Stone and Mike sing an ear splitting acapulco version of Queen’s ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’ before ‘Porch.’
Louise: “We don’t need the guitar – we sing better acapulco”
I thought that maybe I was dreaming – but I wasn’t – when I heard Kirk Franklin, on national television, ask a performer to sing “Acapulco.” (!) The word he wanted was “a cappella.”
http://www.michronicle.com/news/index.p … &Itemid=38
My kids and I often listen to the All A Capella radio show on WERS (Emerson College Radio, Boston.) My nine-year-old used to call the program “a clapella,” an eggcorn-in-the-making if I ever heard one. Without instruments, you have to clap, I suppose. I Googled this, but found only a handful of examples, not one an unambiguous eggcorn. Interesting, anyway.