Discussions about eggcorns and related topics
You are not logged in.
The Eggcorn Forum and the Eggcorn Database are currently in the process of being converted into static sites.
Once the conversion is complete, all existing posts are expected to still be accessible at their original URLs. However, no new posts will be possible.
Feel free to comment on the relevant forum threads.
Chris -- 2025-05-10
Pages: 1
What do you think? It used to be an expression for encouragement by use of a promised reward that could never quite be reached. It seems to have eggcorned into the choice between a reward or a punishment. As the latter is now such a common expression, does it qualify?
Offline
You’ve got it backward. The earliest and only traditional expression is “the carrot OR the stick,” expressing reward vs. punishment. I’ve written this up at
http://www.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/carrot.html
Offline
Interesting. Thank you, Brian. Now I know. I guess I should have checked the OED first.
Offline
The term that I have heard for a reward that it never quite within reach is “dangling a carrot”.
Offline
I always understood it as “carrot on a stick”, refering to dangling a carrot from a stick, just in front of a donkey or horse, so that it will keep moving forward. Giving someone a motivation.
Offline
Pages: 1