eternally » internally

Chiefly in:   internally grateful

Classification: English

Spotted in the wild:

  • If anyone can solve my problem, or tell me how to tell word to open as readonly (I suspect this may solve the problem) I will be internally grateful. (link)
  • I would like to thank Col. Robert Morris for his kind remarks concerning my induction into the Rockabilly Hall of Fame. I am internally grateful and consider it an honor and privilege to be listed among my musical peers and heroes. (link)
  • Oh, and I hate to beg, but if anyone out there fancies surprising me for the holidays I would be internally grateful. (link)

Analyzed or reported by:

| Comments Off link | entered by Chris Waigl, 2005/02/12 |

row » road

Chiefly in:   a tough road to hoe

Variant(s):  a tough road to hold, a tough row to hold, a tough road to row

Classification: English

Spotted in the wild:

  • With only eight matches remaining, the Lions knew it was a tough road to hoe. (link)
  • I feel I let down the fans, the Yankees and my teammates. I accept full responsibility. Most of all to the fans, I am sorry. I understand how they feel. I understand it’s going to be a tough road to hoe but I am going to work my butt off to get back their support. (New York Post, February 11, 2005)
  • A serious parent in our culture today has a hard road to hoe in raising our children to be disciplined, loving, compassionate people. (Honolulu Star Bulletin, July 12, 1999)
  • IT is only part of the effort. Getting people to buy in when you deploy new technology, to change their practices, that’s a tough road to hoe. (link)
  • My family will pray that your Dad wins this battle. It will be a tough road to hold for your entire family, but you will all make it through this. (CRM News, 04 Jun 2002)
  • The biggest task the group faced was trying to get grass growing back on the fairways, something they have been able to accomplish. Even in late January, the fairways were in ideal shape. It was no easy chore and still continues to be a tough row to hold as they continue to battle salt problems with their water supply system. (link)
  • There’s little doubt the Marine City girls basketball team has a tough road to row when it opens district play Monday at Croswell-Lexington High School. (link)

Analyzed or reported by:

  • Joshua Macy at Logomacy (link)

This is a multifaceted eggcorn that appears in many guises. The original expression is _a tough_ (or _hard_) _row to hoe_, from hoeing one’s row (with an actual tool) while working in the field.

The most common reshaping of this idiom is the transformation of _row_ into _road_. Obviously, hoeing a road is even harder.

More rarely, we find an additional substitution: _hoe_ is replaced with _hold_. And occasionally, _row_ is kept but the _hoe_>_hold_ substitution takes place; or the assimilation in /r/ creates an entirely switched-around _tough road to row_.

| 7 comments | link | entered by Chris Waigl, 2005/02/12 |

toe » tow

Chiefly in:   tow the line

Classification: English – nearly mainstream

Spotted in the wild:

  • Rice urged other world leaders to join Washington’s campaign to get “states that continue to support rejectionists and terrorists (to) stop doing that,” while dangling the prospect of further sanctions against Syria if it failed to tow the line. (Reuters, February 8, 2005)
  • Conservative County councillors Brian Gadd and Ron Dyason spoke of their dislike of the scheme and pledged to fight against it, rather than tow the party line. (Bexhill Today, 11 February 2005)
  • Their one-sided, blatant attempts to pressure local cable companies were unethically touted as news on their local broadcasts, with “stories” that were so self-serving I felt pity for the anchors and reporters forced to tow the company line. (link)
  • Lesi is towing the line in Kotobalavu’s direction in support of the 2000 coup. (Fiji Times, February 06, 2005)

Analyzed or reported by:

_Tow the line_ may well be one of the reshapings that will soon be considered acceptable in standard English. It is so common that it is easier to find salient examples in journalistic writing than on the general-purpose web.

Michael Quinion at Word Wide Words explains the original form, _toe the line_:

> Toe the line is the survivor of a set of phrases that were common in the nineteenth century; others were toe the mark, toe the scratch, toe the crack, or toe the trig. In every case, the image was that of men lining up with the tips of their toes touching some line. They might be on parade, or preparing to undertake some task, or in readiness for a race or fight.

The “lining up for a race or fight” metaphor has been obscured, and a new, nautical imagery has been grafted on the expression, thus changing the spelling. In particular when a blend with compounds like _party line_ occurs, the original metaphor slips farther into the background: a party line is not the kind of line that can be toed. And then it is but a step towards towing the line in a particular direction.

An example for the ideas that underpin the semantic reshaping that has taken place is provided in this commentary, on a blog, by a person named Rog:

> Okay, hang on. I’m pretty certain that “toe/tow the line” has a dual etymology, both with a nautical background. Like many such phrases, the meaning has changed over time, giving it multiple connotations.
>
> I don’t doubt that the original was likely “toe”, since that form of punishment (making a sailor stand on deck for long periods of time) is near ancient though undoubtably still in use today.
>
> “Tow the line”, however, is closer to the meaning which people usually are aiming for: to tow in a rope, usually while docking smaller vessels. It implies taking up an open task, doing your share, etc.. as opposed to punishment for a lack of duty.

A very convincing argument, but pure invention, without any foundation in the history of English.

(See also tow » toe.)

| 9 comments | link | entered by Chris Waigl, 2005/02/11 |

barred » barrel

Chiefly in:   no holds barrel

Variant(s):  no holds barreled

Classification: English – vocalized /l/ – idiom-related

Spotted in the wild:

  • Looking at the sex scene in Bangkok and other areas of Thailand on any night about town. This is a no-holds-barrel report with places, attractions, prices and what to really expect. (link)
  • The discussion leader was energetic and informative. He was truthful in his presentation and his ‘no holds barrel’ approach makes the realism of this course so much more believable. (link)
  • It could have been great: JC making a real, excessive, no-holds-barreled, hong-kong movie… (link)
  • About the information published, it is absolutely ground breaking and no holds barrelled. Keep it up! (link)
  • Described as a no-holds barrel death match, Battle Mode can be quite exhilarating thanks to the jump pads spaced throughout the rolling hills. (link)
  • Ken Shamrock, the first King of Pancrase, three-time Ultimate Fighting Superfight Champion, winner of numerous bar brawls and Toughman wars, widely regarded as the finest no-holds-barrel fighter in the world, is being booed. (link)

Phonetically, _no holds barrel(ed)_ involves an old acquaintance: the vocalized /l/, which we’ve already documented in _wheel barrow>wheel barrel_, _bogged down>balked down_ and _handful>hand few_.

Semantically, this eggcorn is a little more obscure. The wrestling metaphor (”no manner of grasping the opponent is forbidden”) has been lost, but what is it replaced with? The idea of barrels that don’t hold whatever they supposedly contain? Barrels without handles, so that you can’t hold on to them?

As for the form in /-ed/, we know of double-, single-, long-, or short-barreled guns, and barreled beer.

Exactly what meaning or underlying metaphor inspired the various occurrences is not entirely clear.

See also _no holes barred_.

| Comments Off link | entered by Chris Waigl, 2005/02/11 |

heap » heave

Chiefly in:   heave scorn on

Classification: English

Spotted in the wild:

  • The public followed Lindbergh’s life with fascination, adoring him as the hero who made the first trans-Atlantic flight; grieving for him when his son was kidnapped and found dead; and heaved scorn on him for his image as a Nazi sympathizer. (Brick Township Bulletin, February 12, 2003)
  • The problem is that Bush, who once heaved contempt on the United Nations, now realizes that Brahimi is his only hope for an exit strategy or a coherent Iraqi strategy of any sort—which he desperately needs before the November election. (Slate, May 24, 2004)
  • While the other candidates tried to be convivial to each other, Ken heaved contempt on everyone else. His relish for beating up other Conservatives is probably why he is popular with the country. (Guardian, July 8, 2001)
  • In the haste to heave contempt at the Cardinals, though, one essential point has been forgotten: A deal’s a deal. (link)

Analyzed or reported by:

| Comments Off link | entered by Chris Waigl, 2005/02/10 |