Discussions about eggcorns and related topics
You are not logged in.
Registrations are temporarily closed as we're receiving a steady stream of registration spam.
Anyone who wishes to register, please email me at chris dot waigl at gmail dot com with the desired username and a valid email address, and I will register you manually.
Thanks for your understanding.
Chris -- 2011-03-08
Recently I stumbled upon this one:
In 2012 Kay (and “Of By For” producer Chad Monnin) became disenfranchised with the current political landscape and wanted to measure publicsentiment.
It seemed clear that the writer really meant a different word, probably “disenchanted”. A little searching found this blog which discusses the misuse of “disenfranchised”, but assumes it’s a substitution for “disillusioned”. I think “disenchanted” is the more likely acorn here, because of the greater pronunciation similarity. In fact, the pronunciation similarity between “disenfranchised” and “disenchanted” may arguably be enough to place this substitution in eggcorn territory. The meaning connection would be that disenfranchisement can be expected to be highly correlated with disenchantment (and with disillusion too, for that matter).
Googling “disenfranchised with” yielded 679 purportedly unique hits, most of which are this (arguably) eggcornish usage.
A fugitive Dog Boy who became disenfranchised with the Coalition, Butch was recruited by Lance Andrews from a small band of bounty hunters in Tolkeen.
fan fiction site
...many centists who vote Republican may become increasingly disenfranchised with the extremist tenancies of the GOP…
Obsessed with photography, architecture, and psychology but recently disenfranchised with politics :(.
In the Cold War, workers everywhere became disenfranchised with the society they lived in and so declared themselves Communist.
article about ID cards
You’re somewhat disenfranchised with the American political system, and you feel like there’s nobody in Washington who represents you.
I have withheld from registering for a long time and have tried to ignore your posts, but I fear that too many people read them and become disenfranchised with products based upon your opinions.
The club is not what it was 10 years ago, and I find myself more and more disenfranchised with the game at the highest levels.
If the grass roots are disenfranchised with the party, we can lose elections.
The preponderance of political examples suggests that this substitution often has lots to do with a kind of smearing of the meanings between “disenfranchised” and “disenchanted”.
I’d call this a malapropism but not an eggcorn. Many malaprops have a meaning connection, sure, but the perps are not thinking the eggcorn meaning and making it fit into the acorn context. In this case, I don’t suppose they are thinking “I can no longer vote”, just failing to realize that that’s what disenfranchised is supposed to mean. If it’s toned way down to “I no longer have any influence”, well, maybe …
I think disengaged is probably in this blurry spot somewhere as well.
we would be too simple-minded to understand it* .